Why a Bengaluru company’s ‘hiring ban’ on men from four northern states is flawed

A Bengaluru company's hiring ban on men from four northern states is flawed, according to Scroll.in.

The full report

A Bengaluru company, A1 Sports World, has sparked controversy by declaring a hiring ban on men from the four states of Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Bihar, and Madhya Pradesh. The company's founder, Karthik Shenoy, cited a male employee's alleged abuse of female colleagues as the reason for the ban. However, the company's stance has been criticized for being flawed, as it discriminates against individuals based on their place of origin. Article 15 of the Indian Constitution bars the state from discriminating on grounds that include place of birth, and private companies should hold themselves to the same principle.

According to Shenoy, the employee had been warned twice about his abusive behaviour before being fired. However, the company's handling of the abuse complaint has been questioned, as it was not handled through the company's internal committee, which is required by the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace Act, 2013. Research on workplace abuse suggests that it is rooted in wider economic, social, and cultural contexts, including entrenched gender roles. The International Labour Organisation's 2022 global survey on violence and harassment at work also examines the barriers that keep people from reporting it.

Shenoy's hiring policy is aimed at the Hindi heartland states, but the forces that contribute to workplace abuse are not unique to these regions. Filtering out potential employees by place of origin punishes an entire category of men for one man's behaviour. Research on workplace harassment points to consistent measures that reduce workplace harassment, including a reporting culture, employee training, and physical design and logistics. Companies should pay attention to these measures to create a safer work environment.

The 2022 International Labour Organisation's research and occupational safety studies suggest that companies with more women in senior roles tend to develop safer, more accountable cultures. A1 Sports World's hiring ban is a temporary measure, but it is not a solution to the problem of workplace harassment. The company should focus on implementing consistent measures to reduce workplace harassment and create a safer work environment for all employees.