NewNWS newsroom live◌Local weatherLocating…--°H --° · L --°Thursday 19 November 2026--:--:--AEDT · Sydney
NewNWSThe Global DeskThe world, in sharper focus.
Live wire
Politics · Global desk · Single-source report

Federal court orders protestors to cover a portion of South Australian government legal fees

Edwin Kemp Attrill and Janette Milera were ordered to pay $150,000 after their challenge to the North Adelaide Golf Course redevelopment was rejected.

· Published · 2 min read
North Adelaide Golf Course (13602311284)
Archive photograph: North Adelaide Golf Course (13602311284) Photo: Michael Coghlan from Adelaide Australia Licence: CC BY-SA 2.0 Source ↗ Licence details ↗

The story

A Federal Court ruling on Thursday required two litigants to contribute $150,000 toward the South Australian government's legal expenses related to the North Adelaide Golf Course upgrade. The order was issued by Judge Natalie Charlesworth after the plaintiffs, public servant Edwin Kemp Attrill and Kaurna community member Janette Milera, unsuccessfully sought to stop the project.

The plaintiffs argued that the redevelopment, which includes the removal of 585 trees, violated federal conservation legislation. Justice Charlesworth found the evidence insufficient to demonstrate that the plans were likely to have a significant impact on protected species, and therefore dismissed the challenge in October.

The state government has estimated its total legal costs at between $450,000 and $550,000. Earlier, the government offered the plaintiffs a $150,000 settlement, which they declined. Following the court's decision, the government applied for a costs order, which the court granted. The plaintiffs' legal representation was provided on a pro bono basis.

A closer look

In response, Kemp Attrill indicated that the costs order could lead to financial hardship, noting that a GoFundMe campaign had raised $132,000 to support the legal fight. Their barrister argued that the case was pursued purely in the public interest and asked the judge to consider special circumstances when determining costs. The government's lawyer rejected the request for a reduced order but did not object to the $150,000 figure.

The decision concludes a legal dispute that centered on the balance between development of public parkland and the protection of native trees, a matter that has drawn attention from environmental groups and the Kaurna community.


Single-source report

This report presents the named publisher’s account and has not yet been independently corroborated.